Buying a used car can be one of life’s great adventures — or one of its most frustrating headaches. If you discover major problems soon after purchase, you may wonder: Does South Carolina’s lemon law protect me? The short answer is no — not in the traditional way. But that doesn’t mean you’re out of options. This article explains everything you need to know about used car protections in South Carolina, in clear language for everyday people and detailed enough for legal professionals advising clients.
What is a Lemon Law?
A “lemon law” generally refers to a state statute that provides special rights and remedies to consumers who buy vehicles that repeatedly fail to meet basic performance and safety standards. These laws require manufacturers to either replace or refund the cost of a defective car that can’t be fixed after a reasonable number of repair attempts.
However, in South Carolina, the traditional lemon law applies mostly to new vehicles — not used ones.
South Carolina’s Lemon Law: New vs. Used Cars
New Cars Are Covered
South Carolina’s official lemon law — the Enforcement of Motor Vehicle Express Warranty Act — applies to new vehicles purchased or leased and registered in the state. These protections are designed to help consumers when a new car suffers from a serious defect that substantially impairs its use, value, or safety and cannot be fixed after a reasonable number of attempts.
For a new car to qualify, it must:
- Be sold and registered in South Carolina,
- Have defects that seriously impact its use, value, or safety,
- Have repair issues noticed within the warranty period or within the first 12,000 miles or 12 months,
- And the manufacturer failed after multiple repair attempts or the car was in the shop for a significant number of cumulative days.
If these conditions are met, the manufacturer must either refund your money or replace the vehicle.
👉 But that doesn’t apply in the same way to used cars.
Used Cars Are Not Covered by South Carolina’s Lemon Law
South Carolina’s lemon law does not automatically apply to used cars simply because a consumer finds a defect after purchase. In other words:
✔ If you buy a car that has already been titled and used by someone else, even if it immediately shows major problems, the state’s lemon law does not grant a guaranteed refund or replacement.
This is an important point for everyday buyers — and a critical distinction for attorneys advising clients who think their “lemon” issue might trigger lemon law remedies.
Does Any Lemon-Style Protection Exist for Used Cars?
Even though the state lemon law doesn’t cover used vehicles directly, other legal protections may help you — depending on the situation.
Here are the key areas to understand:
- Original Manufacturer’s Warranty
If the used vehicle is still covered by the original manufacturer’s warranty, and the issue relates to a defect that the warranty covers, you may have rights similar to lemon law protections — but only under the warranty terms and potentially federal law.
This means:
- If the defect is a covered part,
- And the manufacturer fails to fix it after a reasonable number of attempts,
- You might be able to demand repair, refund, or replacement under the warranty or Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act (a federal law that enforces warranty rights).
Important: Extended warranties or third-party contracts usually do not qualify under state lemon law protections — only the original manufacturer warranty might help.
- Dealer Warranties and Promises
When you buy a used car, the dealer may offer a written warranty or make specific promises about the condition of the vehicle. These promises can be legally binding — even if the state lemon law doesn’t apply.
For example:
- A dealer says the car comes with a 30-day warranty on major systems;
- If they fail to honor it, you may have a breach of contract claim.
This is not lemon law per se, but it is a legal avenue to pursue compensation or repair.
- Implied Warranties
Under South Carolina law, certain implied warranties may automatically apply to dealer sales, including:
- Implied Warranty of Merchantability — the vehicle is fit for ordinary use.
However, dealers can sell cars “as-is,” which often disclaims implied warranties. If the car was sold as-is and that was clearly disclosed, this protection may not apply.
- South Carolina Unfair Trade Practices Act (SCUTPA)
If a dealer engaged in deceptive acts — such as lying about the car’s condition, hiding a salvage title, or misrepresenting repairs — you may have a claim under the South Carolina Unfair Trade Practices Act.
This is powerful because:
- You can recover actual damages,
- In some cases, up to triple your damages plus attorney’s fees.
This Act is one of the strongest tools a consumer has when lemon law doesn’t apply to a used car.
Real-World Example
Imagine you buy a 2018 sedan from a dealer in Charleston. It came with a 12-month/12,000-mile remaining manufacturer warranty. After a few weeks, the transmission slips and the dealer can’t fix it after multiple attempts.
Because:
- The vehicle has a remaining manufacturer warranty,
- The defect significantly impairs the car,
- The manufacturer has been unable to repair it…
…you might have rights under the warranty and possible federal support through the Magnuson-Moss Act — even though the state lemon law doesn’t automatically kick in for used cars.
Steps to Take if You Have Problems With a Used Car
Gather All Paperwork
Collect:
- The bill of sale or purchase agreement,
- Warranty documents (manufacturer and dealer),
- All repair orders and receipts,
- A log of all communication with dealer and manufacturer.
Identify What Type of Protection You Have
- Is the original manufacturer warranty still valid?
- Did the dealer make any written promises?
- Was the car sold “as-is”?
Contact the Dealer and Manufacturer in Writing
If a warranty applies, start with written notices about the defect and request repair, refund, or replacement, following the warranty terms. Certified mail or email receipts help solidify your record.
Consider Legal Remedies
If the dealer:
- Hides material information,
- Misrepresents the condition,
- Or fails to honor promises,
…you may have a claim under SCUTPA or breach of warranty law. These can sometimes recover more than lemon law remedies.
When to Talk to a Lawyer
Everyday buyers should strongly consider legal consultation when:
- The defect is serious,
- The dealer refuses to fix under warranty,
- You believe there was deception or fraud.
For attorneys, key issues will include:
- What warranties are in play (manufacturer vs. dealer),
- Whether the dealer clearly disclosed “as-is” sale,
- Whether there were deceptive acts under SCUTPA,
- What documentation supports the client’s claims.
Bottom Line: Used Cars and Lemon Law in South Carolina
✔ Traditional lemon law protections don’t automatically apply to used cars — state statute covers mainly new vehicles.
✔ Used cars under a manufacturer’s warranty might still have recourse through warranty enforcement or federal laws like Magnuson-Moss.
✔ Dealer promises and implied warranties can create legal obligations if misrepresented.
✔ Unfair trade practices law is often the best avenue if a dealer engaged in deception.
Final Thoughts
Buying a used car doesn’t come with the same lemon law safety net that new car buyers enjoy in South Carolina. But that doesn’t mean you’re powerless. By understanding warranties, keeping detailed records, and knowing which laws protect you, everyday buyers and legal professionals alike can navigate disputes with confidence and, often, achieve meaningful relief even when the traditional lemon law doesn’t apply.
About the Author
